S trap VS P trap | Which one is better and why (2024)

Overview of P-Trap and S-Trap Toilets

Plumbing may seem complicated with all its twists and turns, especially when it comes to toilets. All parts are crucial for the smooth operation of these systems. Two important yet commonly overlooked components are the P-Trap and S-Trap toilets. Luckily international plumbing codes have figured it out for us and tell us that p traps are better.

P-Trap explained

Let’s begin with the P-Trap toilet. The term “P-Trap” refers to the shape of the pipe that is connected to the bottom of your toilet. The shape resembles a ‘P’ on its side, with a slight bend that dips downward before curling upwards. They’re commonly found in North American homes.

So, why this peculiar design? It’s not for aesthetics but rather, for functionality. It plays a major role in maintaining a pleasant bathroom environment. That downward dip holds a bit of water after each flush, creating a seal. This water seal prevents sewer gases from escaping back up through your toilet and filling your home with an unpleasant odor. Besides that, it also stops small creatures from entering through the sewage lines.

S-trap explained

Now, let’s tackle the S-Trap toilet. Just like the P-Trap, this one gets its name from the shape of its pipe, which resembles an ‘S’. Furthermore, it functions quite similarly to its ‘P’ counterpart.

The ‘S’ shaped pipe also accumulates a small quantity of water after every flush, creating a barrier against unpleasant smells and unwelcome critters. However, these are more commonly found in older homes or those with the plumbing system installed towards the floor. With the modernization of plumbing, P-traps became the standard.

To summarize, both P-Trap and S-Trap toilets operate on the same basic principle of creating a water barrier to prevent sewer gas return. However, their designs differ due to the varied structures of the homes or buildings they’re installed in. Being aware of this can save a lot of headaches when it comes to their maintenance or if any issues occur, as the solutions can differ slightly between them.

Whether you have a P-Trap or S-Trap toilet, regular maintenance and cleaning are vital. Keep an eye out for potential issues such as draining problems or abnormal smells. Timely detection can help prevent minor problems from turning into major headaches. Ultimately, taking good care of these critical structures will maintain a clean, safe, and odor-free bathroom.

Differences between P-trap toilets and S-trap toilets

While both share commonalities in name and function, there are some distinct differences between P-trap and S-trap toilets that every homeowner should be aware of. These differences primarily revolve around the design of the trap, which is key to preventing unwanted odors and creatures from rising up from the sewer lines.

P-trap toilets are predominantly seen in high-rise buildings and are favored due to their ability to connect directly to the wall. This makes for a tidy appearance, especially in tight quarters.

Unlike P-trap toilets, S-traps connect directly to the floor, which is ideal for homes and spaces that don’t have in-wall plumbing systems. S-traps are also known for their deeper seal depth, which can often mean a higher degree of protection against sewer gas escape compared to P-traps.

Another primary difference between these two types of toilets lies in their installation process. Due to its design, P-trap toilets have a straightforward installation process when connecting to in-wall plumbing systems. However, installing S-trap toilets can sometimes pose more of a challenge and may require some additional piping work if you’re transitioning from a previous P-trap set-up.

Maintenance is key

When it comes to maintenance, both P-trap and S-trap toilets need regular cleaning and timely attention to any issues that may arise. This ultimately ensures the longevity of your bathroom sanitation system and keeps everything running smoothly.

In terms of water consumption, both toilet designs are similar but can vary based on the manufacturer and model. It’s always best to review the specifications before making a purchase, especially if water efficiency is a key consideration for you.

Should an issue arise with your P-trap or S-trap toilet, knowing their unique features and differences will make troubleshooting that much easier. Whether it’s a persistent odor, unusual noises, or slow flushing, understanding the basic mechanics of your toilet can lead you straight to the source of the problem. This knowledge can save you time and potentially spare you unnecessary expenses on service calls or parts.

In conclusion, whilst both the P-trap and S-trap toilets are essential parts of any well-functioning bathroom sanitation system, they each have their unique features and nuances that set them apart. By understanding these differences, homeowners can make knowledgeable decisions while navigating the complex world of plumbing and sanitation.

Pros and Cons

The P-Trap and S-Trap toilets have both proven to meet specific needs and preferences in different home setups. Bearing that in mind, knowing the pros and cons of each trap toilet is essential for the decision-making process. From personal experiences to interactions with customers, one thing is clear: Both P-Trap and S-Trap toilets come with their advantages and disadvantages.

P-trap toilet Pros and cons

Advantages of P-Trap toilets include their suitability for high-rise buildings, primarily due to the lateral pipe that connects to the wall, thus reducing the risk of water leaks onto the floors below. Also, they offer better protection against sewer gases, as their shaped trap holds a larger body of water that blocks gas from rising.

On the other hand, one significant disadvantage of the P-Trap toilets lies in their complexity of installation. The process can be challenging, especially where the plumbing outlet is meant to be through the floor and not the wall. An additional disadvantage is that P-Trap toilets can be susceptible to blockages, due in part to their sharp, angular bend.

S-trap toilet pros and cons

Turning our attention to S-Trap toilets, one distinct advantage is their adaptability to homes without in-wall plumbing. Also, their less complex installation makes them suitable for a DIY job, saving on costs. They are also better at preventing critters and small rodents from crawling up from the sewer into the toilet bowl.

Despite these strengths, S-Traps have their downsides. They are not as effective as P-Traps in the prevention of sewer gas escapes. This is because the water barrier in the S-Pipe may easily siphon away, leaving the path clear for sewer gases. Additionally, they are not favored in high-rise residential buildings due to potential leaking risks on the floors below.

When considering the water consumption of these toilets, both remain quite similar with insignificant variations. They are both designed to use nominal quantities of water, depending on the model and manufacturer. Want to know how much water your toilet consumes and how to change it? Click here.

Of course, no matter the type of toilet you choose, regular maintenance and swift resolution of any issues will ensure a longer lifespan and better function. Watch for signs of either P or S traps related problems like bad odors, slow flush, or visible leaks, and address them promptly.

Troubleshooting Guide for P-Trap and S-Trap Toilets

One significant problem that may appear with P-Trap toilets is the occurrence of blockages. These blockages can occur if too much solid waste or non-flushable items (think wipes, feminine hygiene products, etc.) are flushed down the toilet. The solution here is usually a good old-fashioned toilet plunger or a toilet auger for tougher clogs. Sure, it’s not the most glamorous of tasks, but it’s effective.

Shifting focus to S-Trap toilets, one problem that could arise is the leaking of sewer gases into the building. This especially incurs in high-rise buildings, leading to unpleasant smells. The best solution for this is to have a licensed plumber inspect and assess the situation. They’ll likely suggest altering the plumbing setup, for example, by converting the S-Trap to a P-Trap if the situation permits.

Remember, regardless of the type of toilet, regular maintenance is the key to ensure longevity and efficient functioning. If troubles are spotted promptly, it saves time, effort, and most importantly, a lot of money in the long run.

So, when it comes to choosing between the two, the structure of the bathroom and specific needs should be put under consideration. It’s less about which is ‘better’ and more about which suits ‘you’ better. At the end of the day, remember toilets aren’t just about aesthetics; like a trusty assistant, they work intelligently and silently in the background, contributing significantly to our health and hygiene.

_{Disclaimer: TheToiletSpecialist.com is not responsible for any damage caused to your toilet and surroundings by (wrongly) interpreting information found on this site. Please seek custom advice from a professional to evaluate your current situation.}

^{This article may contain affiliate links at no extra cost to you. AF links help support this blog so that it can exist and expand for years to come!}